The flow of documents
The two letters were registered on July 30 and by August 5, the Cabinet Secretary had forwarded them to the officials of the Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) and the office of the Chief Election Commissioner. However, the contents of the letters have not been made public yet.
The Cabinet Secretariat did not release the 14-page document (which includes a 10-page letter from the commissioners, a two-page reply and a two-page file note) until a fee of Rs 28 was paid.
Why did the election commissioners write the letter?
The reason behind this was an order on the distribution of work issued on July 28. According to a newspaper report, the two commissioners had written to the Cabinet Secretary objecting to the order, calling it a violation of rules. The new distribution order was later quashed. This change effectively removed a layer of oversight over the IT infrastructure of the electoral rolls. The commissioners further clarified that the changes were made without their knowledge. The move was described as a ‘radical departure from the established practice’.
Meanwhile, another newspaper quoted a person familiar with the matter as saying that the letter was not written to Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar but to a senior deputy election commissioner. The Election Commission clarified its position in a press release on September 26.
It said, “The letter sent to the Cabinet Secretary was not related to any policy matter of the Commission or the IT department. Rather, it was related to the work of an officer working on deputation in the Election Commission (ECI). The orders regarding redistribution of work issued by the officer concerned (after the directions of the two commissioners) were not implemented in practice. Moreover, the supervision of the Deputy Election Commissioner (DEC) over the IT department was never withdrawn.” What was revealed through RTI
It is not clear from the information obtained through RTI in response to a query by the pan-India media ‘India Today’ that what exactly the two commissioners wrote in their letters or what their specific allegations were. The RTI reply did not reveal the contents of the letters.
However, this is the first official document in a controversy that has largely been based on leaked information and press notes. It confirms that the letters actually existed, when they arrived and where the Cabinet Secretary’s reply was sent.
What happens next
India Today will pay a fee of Rs 28. Once the documents are received, this report will be updated with what the commissioners wrote and the Cabinet Secretary’s reply.
The Cabinet Secretariat is the highest administrative body of the Government of India. It is located in the Seva Tirtha Bhavan. It also houses the Prime Minister’s Office and the National Security Council Secretariat. The fee of Rs. 28 required for obtaining the documents can be deposited through Demand Draft, Banker's Cheque, Indian Postal Order or cash with proper receipt.
There is currently no digital payment facility in the Secretariat for payment of this fee.